Alternate Ending (The Giver)

Avatar for username SodaPop

17 years old

Log in or register to post comments.

More by SodaPop

A meaningless encounter, best friendship.

Forgotten password

Please enter the email address that you use to login to TeenInk.com, and we'll email you instructions to reset your password.

  • Poetry All Poetry Free Verse Song Lyrics Sonnet Haiku Limerick Ballad
  • Fiction All Fiction Action-Adventure Fan Fiction Historical Fiction Realistic Fiction Romance Sci-fi/Fantasy Scripts & Plays Thriller/Mystery All Novels Action-Adventure Fan Fiction Historical Fiction Realistic Fiction Romance Sci-fi/Fantasy Thriller/Mystery Other
  • Nonfiction All Nonfiction Bullying Books Academic Author Interviews Celebrity interviews College Articles College Essays Educator of the Year Heroes Interviews Memoir Personal Experience Sports Travel & Culture All Opinions Bullying Current Events / Politics Discrimination Drugs / Alcohol / Smoking Entertainment / Celebrities Environment Love / Relationships Movies / Music / TV Pop Culture / Trends School / College Social Issues / Civics Spirituality / Religion Sports / Hobbies All Hot Topics Bullying Community Service Environment Health Letters to the Editor Pride & Prejudice What Matters
  • Reviews All Reviews Hot New Books Book Reviews Music Reviews Movie Reviews TV Show Reviews Video Game Reviews Summer Program Reviews College Reviews
  • Art/Photo Art Photo Videos
  • Summer Guide Program Links Program Reviews
  • College Guide College Links College Reviews College Essays College Articles

Summer Guide

College guide.

  • Song Lyrics

All Fiction

  • Action-Adventure
  • Fan Fiction
  • Historical Fiction
  • Realistic Fiction
  • Sci-fi/Fantasy
  • Scripts & Plays
  • Thriller/Mystery

All Nonfiction

  • Author Interviews
  • Celebrity interviews
  • College Articles
  • College Essays
  • Educator of the Year
  • Personal Experience
  • Travel & Culture

All Opinions

  • Current Events / Politics
  • Discrimination
  • Drugs / Alcohol / Smoking
  • Entertainment / Celebrities
  • Environment
  • Love / Relationships
  • Movies / Music / TV
  • Pop Culture / Trends
  • School / College
  • Social Issues / Civics
  • Spirituality / Religion
  • Sports / Hobbies

All Hot Topics

  • Community Service
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Pride & Prejudice
  • What Matters

All Reviews

  • Hot New Books
  • Book Reviews
  • Music Reviews
  • Movie Reviews
  • TV Show Reviews
  • Video Game Reviews

Summer Program Reviews

  • College Reviews
  • Writers Workshop
  • Regular Forums
  • Program Links
  • Program Reviews
  • College Links

The Giver Alternate Ending

The unruly, snow-covered path in front of them was winding with a thousand hills, one after another. Each one had a tipping point, a second when you stood tallest before you're next step brought you a view of what lays ahead. It was at those points that Jonas truly discovered what hope was. Each time he would stop, and feel, with every part of himself, that he would look down and see elsewhere. It was such a solid feeling, even though it was not arrived at by logic it was infinitely more truthful. For that second he would expect elsewhere and every step forward would show him only snow and hills. He soon discovered that disappointment stung in ways that only the return of hope could repair. Jonas had lost track of how long they had been traveling. The days ran together in an expanse of hunger and cold. The thin tunic did little to stop the icy burn from digging into Jonas’s skin. He pulled it tighter around himself. His chapped lips bled from the cold and his body ached for food, but the deepest pain was felt when he looked at Gabriel's frail body. It shook with violent shivers and his glossy eyes were clenched tight against the cold. He was such a small thing. Jonas remembered Gabriel's tiny fist squeezing his hands earlier in their journey but now they rested limp, dangling from his wrists. His face had first been red against the frosty air but it was now a dull grey, dark against the snowflakes on his cheeks. Jonas briefly wondered how he had gotten here and was stricken with a feeling of being completely, and utterly alone. Loneliness, that's what it's called, he thought. He could feel his memories fading. His mind blanked on words he knew like they had been pulled from his brain leaving holes in their wake. It felt like an itch he just couldn't scratch. It made him feel the pain of anger. No that wasn't the right word… Frustration! That's it, he thought. He remembered less and less as the days went on. At the tipping point of each hill, he would feel less hopeful, and less hopeful, until there was no hope left at all. The cold white powder around him was nameless no matter how far into his head he dug. The world had slowly been dimming, the powder was grey now like Gabriel's skin and it ran together with the sky and the trees. Jonas pulled the last piece of food out of his bag, a small apple. He noticed it was the same shade of grey as his hands. He brought it to his lips and took a bite of the flavorless, tasteless, blob. Jonas stopped. He knew he was losing his memories and if he took one more step forward all of his humanity would be lost. He would never feel loved, or go sledding, or see a Christmas tree but the community could do it all. They would be full people, really and truly living. With the last of his strength, he pushed himself forward, sprawling out on the powder covered ground. He tried to remember Christmas and love but they were just empty shells, he had a vague trace of them in his mind but what they meant, what they really were, no longer remained. they continued to fade until even the casings were gone and only blankness was left. Jonas looked down into his arms at the small child he held and tried to remember its name but it was too far gone. The child's lungs heaved slowly, more time spanning between breaths until his chest stilled. His mouth hung open, the last of his air leaving him, and Jonas felt nothing. Jonas could feel the cold enveloping him, burrowing through his skin and into every cell like a wildfire of ice. The hunger dulled as if his body knew that it was the end, he looked into the child's dead eyes and saw himself in them. he took his last breath; a desperate inhale followed by his lungs deflating, it fogged up the air. Jonas’s eyes slowly closed and the world faded into darkness and silence. He woke with a start. Confusion muddled his brain as his eyes adjusted to the light. It was warm. He was sitting on a grassy hill with the sun heating his back. A pleasant wind brushed through stirring the leaves and he could feel blades of grass itching his legs. The sky was blue, bright blue. The clouds were white against it, and the sun was yellow! The apple tree in front of him was brown and the branches carried juicy red apples. He felt a weight in his lap and looked down to see a chubby Gabriel sitting on his legs, a grin spreading his rosy cheeks. Jonas reached out a hand to touch him and felt his warm skin. He could see Gabriel's chest breathing naturally, not a trace of pain anywhere on him. He was overcome with a happiness more intense than he had ever felt before. He swooped Gabe up into his arms and in one swift motion pressed him against his chest in a heartfelt embrace. Jonas could feel himself breathing in the air, it was not heavy or cold, now it was light, and warm, and fresh. Jonas turned his head to the side and say a figure to his left, he pulled his eyes upward and to his surprise saw Rosemary. She looked so different from the video, she was so much older now. her skin was no longer pale, and her hair was full and thick. “Am I dead?” Jonas asked, he had died in the snow, hadn't he? “No” Rosemary replied. Her mouth twitched in a slight smile and her eyes wrinkled ever so slightly with the motion. “Come with me,” she said after a pause. She extended a hand to him to help him up. Jonas eyed it wearily but did not reach out to grab it. “Where are we going,” he asked. “Elsewhere” Rosemary replied, her lips spreading into a full grin. The twinkle in her eye promised adventure. Jonas paused and bit his lip. He took a deep breath and grabbed Rosemary's hand.

this is an alternate ending to the giver set while Jonas and Gabriel are nearing the end of there journey but have not found the sled or seen the lights yet. I wanted to play off of the idea of elsewhere and refresh the symbolism of the apples and color etc. I also wanted to wrap up Jonas's character arc because I thought the bravery and courage he had wasn't very well expanded upon in the book. enjoy, and please review!

Similar Articles

Join the discussion.

This article has 0 comments.

  • Subscribe to Teen Ink magazine
  • Submit to Teen Ink
  • Find A College
  • Find a Summer Program

Share this on

Send to a friend.

Thank you for sharing this page with a friend!

Tell my friends

Choose what to email.

Which of your works would you like to tell your friends about? (These links will automatically appear in your email.)

Send your email

Delete my account, we hate to see you go please note as per our terms and conditions, you agreed that all materials submitted become the property of teen ink. going forward, your work will remain on teenink.com submitted “by anonymous.”, delete this, change anonymous status, send us site feedback.

If you have a suggestion about this website or are experiencing a problem with it, or if you need to report abuse on the site, please let us know. We try to make TeenInk.com the best site it can be, and we take your feedback very seriously. Please note that while we value your input, we cannot respond to every message. Also, if you have a comment about a particular piece of work on this website, please go to the page where that work is displayed and post a comment on it. Thank you!

Pardon Our Dust

Teen Ink is currently undergoing repairs to our image server. In addition to being unable to display images, we cannot currently accept image submissions. All other parts of the website are functioning normally. Please check back to submit your art and photography and to enjoy work from teen artists around the world!

the giver alternate ending assignment

THE GIVER: What is an ambiguous ending?

Author Lois Lowry intentionally left the plot of The Giver unsolved. How did this make you feel? Were you left hanging on the edge of your seat, confused and dazed, or were you possibly mad at the author? Some people enjoy solving the plots themselves. Others feel cheated because they want to know the rest of the story. This activity will allow student to write the rest of the story, based on their feelings and evidence from the book. (This is one of six ALCA lessons over the book.)

Engaging Questions

What was the condition of Jonas and Gabriel toward the end of the journey?

Do you think Jonas might have been hallucinating at the end of his journey?

Why do you think Lois Lowry chose to use the Giver's favorite memory at the end of the journey for Jonas?

Teacher Goals

The students will learn the meaning of an ambiguous ending.

The students will write an alternate ending to the novel The Giver , based on their feelings, personal experience, and the novel's textual evidence.

Required Resources

The novel THE GIVER, by Lois Lowry

  • New Ending for THE GIVER

Optional Resources

Random House web site This site is very interesting, especially because of the fact that it posts a message from Lois Lowry, the author of the Giver.

  • Random House web site

Reading and Reflection

After the students have completed the novel, they should reflect on the final chapter.

The class should discuss the physical conditions of both Jonas and Gabriel.

More Discussion

The class should discuss how the change of weather and landscape made the journey especially difficult.

Considerations

The class should discuss the details of Jonas's final sled ride and consider the outcome.

Alternate Ending

The students should write an alternate ending to the novel, based on their feelings, personal experiences, and the novel's textual evidence. The students will need to have evidence from the novel to back their theory of the ending.

Teacher Notes

The ending of The Giver is discussed openly on the net. Truly, it is left up to the individual reader to determine what became of Jonas and Gabriel.

Learner Notes

The book gives many clues to a possible ending, both in a positive and negative way. Have fun creating a different ending.

Mentor Notes

Please enter a Registration Key to continue.

× Do you know these Musicians from their Movies?

the giver alternate ending assignment

The Giver Book Ending Explained

The Giver Book Ending Explained: Unveiling the Mysteries of the Dystopian Classic

The Giver, written by Lois Lowry, is a dystopian novel that has captivated readers for decades. With its thought-provoking themes and complex storyline, the book has left many readers pondering its enigmatic ending. In this article, we will delve into the final chapters of The Giver, shedding light on its meaning and uncovering hidden truths. Additionally, we will explore seven interesting facts about the book and address fourteen common questions that often arise among readers.

The ending of The Giver has sparked numerous debates and interpretations. It concludes with Jonas, the protagonist, choosing to escape from the seemingly utopian community he has grown up in. Alongside the infant Gabe, Jonas embarks on a treacherous journey towards a better future, leaving readers questioning the outcome of their escape.

1. The Journey to Freedom: The escape represents Jonas’ rebellion against the oppressive society he resides in. It symbolizes his yearning for individuality and freedom of choice, which were suppressed in his community.

2. The Colors of Life: As Jonas ventures beyond the boundaries of his community, he begins to see the world in color. This revelation signifies his newfound ability to experience emotions, contrasting with the emotionless existence he previously lived.

3. The Uncertain Fate: The book’s ambiguous ending leaves the fate of Jonas and Gabe up to interpretation. Some argue that they perish in the harsh conditions, while others believe they find refuge and create a new society based on freedom and individuality.

4. The Sacrifice of the Giver: The Giver, an elder who transmits memories to Jonas, is left behind to guide the community through the painful memories he shared with Jonas. His sacrifice embodies the idea that progress and change often come at a cost.

5. The Fading Memories: Throughout the novel, Jonas learns about the history and emotions of the past. However, as he leaves the community, these memories gradually fade, leaving him uncertain about his own identity and the world he left behind.

6. The Power of Choice: Jonas’ decision to escape symbolizes the strength of individual choice and the importance of challenging oppressive systems. It encourages readers to question authority and strive for a society that values freedom and diversity.

7. The Cycle of Life: The ending of The Giver connects to the broader theme of the cycle of life. As Jonas escapes, he takes on the role of the Giver, passing on memories and knowledge to the next generation, ensuring that history is not forgotten and society can evolve.

Now, let’s address some common questions that often arise when discussing the ending of The Giver:

Q1: Does Jonas survive his journey?

A1: The ending is intentionally ambiguous, leaving the fate of Jonas open to interpretation. Some argue that he perishes, while others believe he finds refuge and creates a new society.

Q2: What happened to the community after Jonas left?

A2: The community is left without Jonas and the Giver. It is implied that they will face challenges and eventually confront the truth about their controlled existence.

Q3: Why did Jonas take Gabe with him?

A3: Jonas takes Gabe because he sees potential in him and believes he deserves a chance at a better life. Gabe represents hope for the future.

Q4: What is the significance of the colors Jonas sees?

A4: The colors represent Jonas’ newfound ability to experience emotions and his departure from the emotionless life in the community.

Q5: How does the ending relate to the theme of freedom?

A5: The ending emphasizes Jonas’ rebellion against the oppressive society and his quest for freedom and individuality.

Q6: What does the Giver’s sacrifice represent?

A6: The Giver’s sacrifice symbolizes the sacrifices necessary for progress and change. He stays behind to guide the community through the memories he shared with Jonas.

Q7: Why did Jonas want to leave the community?

A7: Jonas wanted to leave the community because he realized the lack of individual freedom and the suppression of emotions. He yearned for a life where he could make his own choices.

Q8: Are there sequels to The Giver?

A8: Yes, Lois Lowry has written three companion novels: Gathering Blue, Messenger, and Son. Although not direct sequels, they expand on the themes and events of The Giver.

Q9: What is the role of memories in the book?

A9: Memories play a central role in The Giver, as they provide Jonas with a deeper understanding of the world he lives in and drive him to seek change.

Q10: Does the book have a happy ending?

A10: The ending can be seen as bittersweet, as it offers hope for a better future but leaves many questions unanswered.

Q11: What can we learn from The Giver?

A11: The Giver encourages readers to reflect on the importance of individuality, freedom, and the power of challenging oppressive systems.

Q12: Is The Giver suitable for young readers?

A12: The Giver is often read in middle school or high school classrooms. While it deals with complex themes, it is accessible and can spark meaningful discussions.

Q13: What is the significance of Jonas’ ability to see beyond?

A13: Jonas’ ability to see beyond represents his unique perspective and his potential to challenge the limitations of his community.

Q14: How does the book reflect our own society?

A14: The Giver serves as a cautionary tale, reminding us to question authority and value individuality in the face of restrictive systems.

In conclusion, The Giver’s ending provokes contemplation and offers multiple interpretations. It explores themes of freedom, sacrifice, and the power of memory, leaving readers to question the fate of Jonas and the community he left behind. The book reminds us of the importance of challenging oppressive systems and the value of individuality. As we witness Jonas’ escape, we are inspired to reflect on our own society and the choices we make. As one professional in the field states, “The Giver is a timeless masterpiece that continues to resonate with readers, urging us to examine the world around us and strive for a better future.” Another professional adds, “The book’s ending is both haunting and hopeful, leaving room for interpretation and inspiring readers to imagine the possibilities beyond the final page.” With these thoughts in mind, we are reminded of the enduring power of The Giver and its ability to ignite our imaginations and provoke meaningful conversations about the world we live in.

Related Posts:

The Giver Ending Explained

alternate ending writing

All Formats

Resource types, all resource types.

  • Rating Count
  • Price (Ascending)
  • Price (Descending)
  • Most Recent

Alternate ending writing

Preview of Writing An Alternate Ending - Narrative Assignment for ANY Novel {Grades 7-12}

Writing An Alternate Ending - Narrative Assignment for ANY Novel {Grades 7-12}

the giver alternate ending assignment

  • Google Apps™

Preview of Short Story Alternate Ending Writing Assignment

Short Story Alternate Ending Writing Assignment

the giver alternate ending assignment

Write an Alternate Ending - Book Report Project for Any Novel or Short Story

the giver alternate ending assignment

Alternate Ending Writing Assignment

the giver alternate ending assignment

Alternate Ending Book Report: Write an Alternate Ending for any Fiction Book

the giver alternate ending assignment

Alternate Ending Writing

the giver alternate ending assignment

  • Word Document File

Preview of Editable Rubric for Writing an Alternate Ending to a Story

Editable Rubric for Writing an Alternate Ending to a Story

the giver alternate ending assignment

Writing an Alternate Ending "Rubric"

the giver alternate ending assignment

Write an Alternate Ending - Novel or Short Story Digital Book Report Project

Preview of The Giver by Lois Lowry - Alternate ending writing assignemt

The Giver by Lois Lowry - Alternate ending writing assignemt

the giver alternate ending assignment

Write an Alternate Ending to a Story Assignment

the giver alternate ending assignment

All Summer In A Day Writing Activity | Alternate Ending Writing Activity

the giver alternate ending assignment

Of Mice and Men: Creative Writing Narrative ( Alternate Ending )

the giver alternate ending assignment

Write an Alternate Ending | Reading Comprehension, No Prep, Middle/High School

the giver alternate ending assignment

Creative Writing Alternate Ending for ANY TEXT Middle and High School

the giver alternate ending assignment

"The Run" Alternate Ending Writing Group Project

the giver alternate ending assignment

Writing an Alternate Ending with Dialogue "Rubric"

Preview of Thank You, Ma'am- Alternate Ending Narrative Writing

Thank You, Ma'am- Alternate Ending Narrative Writing

the giver alternate ending assignment

  • Google Docs™

Preview of Hatchet - write an alternate ending

Hatchet - write an alternate ending

the giver alternate ending assignment

Alternate Ending (Reading Comprehension, Writing , Guided Reading)

the giver alternate ending assignment

Jack and the Beanstalk Alternate Ending Writing Page

the giver alternate ending assignment

Bookworms Gr 3 Module 2 Unit 3 Narrative Writing Tall Tale Alternate Ending

the giver alternate ending assignment

  • Google Slides™

Preview of Short Story | Alternate Ending Writing Assignment | Hybrid, In-Person, Virtual

Short Story | Alternate Ending Writing Assignment | Hybrid, In-Person, Virtual

the giver alternate ending assignment

  • Google Drive™ folder

Preview of Alternate Ending Writing Assignment: "It does not have to end this way..."

Alternate Ending Writing Assignment: "It does not have to end this way..."

the giver alternate ending assignment

  • We're hiring
  • Help & FAQ
  • Privacy policy
  • Student privacy
  • Terms of service
  • Tell us what you think

Alternate Endings

Alternate Endings

  • Send me your ideas! Please?
  • Harry Potter (For Appa_Lovegood)

the giver alternate ending assignment

YOU ARE READING

Have you ever just hated the ending of a book, and just completely wanted to change it? Or do you just have a different idea of how a book could have ended? Well, send me your ideas and thoughts and I shall write them down just for you.

# alternate # different # endings

Writer: huffleparker

  • Post to Your Profile
  • Share via Email

icon warning

  • Report Story

A/N: This was an assignment I had to write and I'm going to use it, just to start the story off. So, hope you enjoy it. :) Now... read!

All the snow swirling around Jonas blurred his vision, and the strong cold wind was making it hard to breathe. Still, he had to do this for Gabe. Getting Gabe to Elsewhere safely and unharmed was all that mattered to him. With a few more staggering steps, Jonas had reached the top. His chest filled with victory and pride. He could see lights, hear music and smell a very, very faint smell of food from the distance. But his feelings of pride and victory were quickly replaced by feelings of fear and desperation. There was nothing to let him go down the hill safely. If he walked, he would slip and break a bone as the steep hillside was covered in ice and very little snow. But he would have to try, for Gabriel's sake as the infant would soon start to cry from the cold.

The first few steps down the icy hillside were not too difficult. But the walking down the rest of the hillside was easier said than done. Halfway down, after losing his footing he slipped on the ice and landed hard on the ice his skull making a barely audible cracking noise. He screamed out in pain, his blood dripping onto the white ground. To make it worse, Gabriel started to cry. Jonas tried his best to grasp onto any warm and happy memory, but the pain from his head wound stopped any happy memories from coming to his mind. He rolled onto his back, hugging Gabriel to his chest trying to get the both of them as warm as possible. The snow storm had weakened, but it was still going strong.

This is it, He thought. This is how I'm going to die. And because of me, Gabriel is going to die a worse death than the releasing. At least with the release there would have been less pain. I took him with me when I wasn't even sure I was going to make it to Elsewhere alive and I brought Gabe into this mess. Why couldn't I have left him in my house? Why coul- and before he could finish his thought, everything just went black; the only motion was Gabe's crying body squirming in Jonas' now lifeless grip.

the giver alternate ending assignment

Ask LitCharts AI: The answer to your questions

The Individual vs. Society Theme Icon

The Cinemaholic

The Giver Ending, Explained

 of The Giver Ending, Explained

Imagine a world without colors or emotions, or history for that matter. How would life thrive in such a place? 2014 sci-fi dystopian drama ‘The Giver’ is an epic tale told in snippets. Directed by Phillip Noyce and based on the eponymous 1993 young adult novel by Lois Lowry, the story revolves around the titular Giver and his Receiver in a far-flung futuristic universe.

The mentor-apprentice tale is also the coming-of-age of Jonas. He holds all four abilities to become the Receiver of Memory. Through his eyes, we look at the history of the bygone — the snow, the sled, and the bees — and the world slowly comes to color. Let us revisit the final moments of Jonas’ story. SPOILERS AHEAD.

The Giver Plot Synopsis

Jonas lives in a futuristic world where they cannot have last names. They are rid of pain and suffering, but they are also not allowed to have emotions. When children graduate, the Chief Elder ( Meryl Streep ) thanks the children for their childhoods and initiates them to society according to their abilities. They live in dispersed communities, while Elsewhere remains a buffer zone of the past. Jonas knew from his childhood that he was different.

the giver alternate ending assignment

On graduation day, the Chief Elder virtually meets the community and decides the fate of the graduates. Asher becomes a drone pilot, and Fiona, a nurturer. Jonas, however, holds all the four abilities: intelligence, integrity, courage, and the ability to see beyond. He meets the Giver of Memories ( Jeff Bridges ) — the one who possesses the cumulative memories of the entire humankind — and starts his training. He would come to know that there is more — much more — than the civilization can imagine.

The Giver Ending: What Is The Boundary of Memory? Can Jonas Cross It?

Early in the lessons, Jonas comes to the Giver’s house on the Edge to find him deep in his studies. He utters that there will be a Giver more gifted than all that came before him, and he would be known by the name of Jonas. The Giver also warns Jonas not to be beguiled. He accidentally or willingly drops a map from the book, and Jonas picks it up. The rough map demarcates the world of the communities. Jonas identifies the Triangle of Rocks, which his friend Asher saw in one of his drone adventures.

The map is bound by a line called the Boundary of Memory. The Boundary of Memory keeps the collective memory of humankind out of the community’s reach, in the reign of the Elders. However, Jonas deduces that if he can cross the Boundary of Memory, they can get the memory back for entire communities. The memories can moreover be passed on, as we have seen before. The injections that the Elders prescribe further represses one from having dreams, emotions, and memories.

the giver alternate ending assignment

After the Giver’s suggestions that the injections keep the populace ignorant, Jonas stops taking the medicines altogether. He starts having emotions for Fiona that he cannot describe. The Giver dubs it “love.” But they live in a world where there is no love — “the precision of language” prevails. But Jonas starts showing aberrant behaviors, which raises suspicion amongst his parents and the Chief Elder.

Meanwhile, the family keeps Gabriel, a child who has the same birthmark on his wrist as Jonas. Jonas knows that Gabriel, too, would be a Giver of Memory. Jonas passes on all the happy memories from the Giver to Gabriel. But when Jonas sees his father “releasing” Gabriel (a term assigned to killing), he becomes hellbent on charting the lands of Elsewhere beyond the Boundary of Memory.

Gabriel must be killed for not meeting the development criterion, and Jonas cannot let that happen. Jonas tells Fiona to leave with him, but Fiona conforms in the end. Jonas steals a kiss from Fiona and punches Asher before fleeing the scene with Gabriel. He hops on a bike and the police chase after him. But Jonas manages to take the leap from the Edge, and the police have to bring the pursuit to a close. Jonas crosses a desert, while the Chief Elder tells Asher to capture and eliminate Jonas.

Asher follows the party with his drone, but Jonas’ pleading makes Asher let him go. They float down the river and interestingly reach a range of mountains. We almost see the re-enactment of ‘ Into The Wild ,’ but Jonas wakes up on the snow to find a sled — just like in his first session with the Giver. He rides the sled to reach a home, which is more than just a dwelling. In the end, the Giver leads Jonas into Elsewhere. We see the world coming back to technicolor in the finale, and the collective memories come back to the Chief Elder. Therefore, we can safely assume that he has gone beyond the Boundary of Memory.

Is Fiona Dead or Alive? Do Jonas And Fiona End Up Together?

The Chief Elder and Jonas’ mother see the video of Jonas kissing Fiona. Jonas has expressed his love for Fiona, but the desire is forbidden to maintain sameness in this dystopian world. Therefore, they conjure that Fiona must be released. After Jonas’ instruction, Fiona stops taking the medications altogether, which may cause her to have emotions. Jonas’ mother gives Fiona the morning injection while Jonas’ father prepares to release her.

the giver alternate ending assignment

However, right before Jonas’ father can push the injection, Jonas crosses the boundary. The memories come back to everyone, and Fiona is saved. But Jonas is in Elsewhere, and we do not know whether the lovers meet again. In the end, Jonas says that he knows about their future meet, which can be possible. In a dream, Jonas dances with Fiona at a wedding. If the civilization goes back to a primitive time after the reveal, maybe Jonas and Fiona will meet sometime in the future. As Fiona is still alive, there is also a possibility of her following Jonas into Elsewhere.

Who Is Rosemary?

Before Jonas, they chose a girl as the Receiver of Memory. On the first day of Jonas’ training, the Giver and Jonas have a hearty conversation. But when Jonas pryingly asks about the previous Receiver, the Giver stays mum. He reveals the story later through projections. In one of the projections, we see a woman teaching piano to the Giver. This woman, we come to know, is Rosemary (Taylor Swift plays a sweet cameo role).

the giver alternate ending assignment

Snippets show that Rosemary was a gifted student who would love to argue with the Giver. However, one day, the Giver gave her the memories of war. She never returned and was later released. But we do not know of her origins until the final moments. When Fiona is executed, the memory of Rosemary comes back to the Giver. He calls Rosemary her daughter, and we come to understand her importance in the story. The loss of Rosemary gives the Giver’s character another layer of tragedy.

Read More: Where Was The Giver Filmed?

SPONSORED LINKS

The Cinemaholic Sidebar

  • Movie Explainers
  • TV Explainers
  • About The Cinemaholic

Assignments

  • View history

Assignments are the occupations of the inhabitants of the Community . Assignments are designated when a member of the Community goes through their respective Ceremony of Twelve .

All Assignments can be found here .

  • 1.1 The Giver

History [ ]

The giver [ ].

Claire is given the Assignment of Birthmother at the Ceremony of Twelve.

Coming soon...

  • Assignments are made by the Elders may be appealed by contacting them, who form a committee to discuss it. Committees typically take a large amount of time to decide so an appeal is considered to be impractical.

IMAGES

  1. The Giver Alternate Ending Writing Assignment by Megan Altman

    the giver alternate ending assignment

  2. The Giver: The Alternate Ending

    the giver alternate ending assignment

  3. The Giver Alternate Ending Narrative Writing Task 1 .docx

    the giver alternate ending assignment

  4. THE GIVER

    the giver alternate ending assignment

  5. Alternate Ending to the Giver Essay Example

    the giver alternate ending assignment

  6. The Giver by Lois Lowry

    the giver alternate ending assignment

VIDEO

  1. School giver utopia assignment

  2. 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩PROOF THAT THIS WITCH IS NOT A GIVER 😩😩😩😩😩

  3. The Giver Alternate ending

  4. Getting the genocide ending in "More Students Mod"

  5. Genocide ending without garbage bags or bookbags

  6. Changed [Part 4.2] To Leave

COMMENTS

  1. New Ending Activity for The Giver

    Start by discussing the ending of The Giver. Did you like the unresolved ending? Why do you think Lois Lowry chose to end The Giver this way? ... Students can then start on the assignment: writing an alternative ending for The Giver. Before students begin writing, they should consider the following: 1) Jonas and Gabriel are cold, tired and ...

  2. PDF Alternate EndingGeneral Requirements

    Alternate EndingGeneral Requirements: The purpose for the Alternate Ending assignment isto demonstrate your understanding of The Giver. The ending must: • be a minimum of two typed pages • be Double spaced • be 12-14 point font -preferably Times New Romanor Calibri • include asetting, character traits, tone, and mood consistent with the ...

  3. alternative ending

    Students can then start on the assignment: writing an alternative ending for The Giver. Before students begin writing, they should consider the following: 1) Jonas and Gabriel are cold, tired and getting weaker. How does Jonas find the strength to go on?

  4. The Giver Lesson Plans

    Below are 10 quick lesson plan ideas for teaching The Giver by Lois Lowry. If you want detailed daily lesson plans and everything else you need to teach The Giver in one easy download, check out this amazing full unit plan. Lesson Ideas 1. Introduction to the novel: Before diving into the book, introduce students to the basic plot and themes of ...

  5. Alternate Ending (The Giver)

    Alternate Ending (The Giver) Jonas awoke from a restless sleep, filled with nightmares of faceless people attacking him and ripping Gabe from his arms. His clothes were stained with tears, but Gabe was still wrapped tight in his arms, shivering. The rain hadn't stopped, but they had managed to find a tree with long arms stretching around them ...

  6. Alternative ending

    Alternative ending to the Giver. Jonas ran towards the music as fast as his legs could carry him. Gabe stirred and opened his eyes weakly. "We're here Gabe!" he whispered, feeling excited and quite certain that he had reached his destination after so long. Gabe stared back with emotionless eyes.

  7. The Giver Alternate Ending Writing Assignment

    Description. In this writing assignment based on The Giver by Lois Lowry, students are asked to write an alternate ending to the novel. Total Pages. 1 page. Answer Key. N/A. Teaching Duration. 30 minutes. Report this resource to TPT.

  8. The Giver Alternate Ending

    The Giver Alternate Ending. February 27, 2018. By harperkole BRONZE, Memphis, Tennessee. More by this author. The unruly, snow-covered path in front of them was winding with a thousand hills, one ...

  9. The Giver by Lois Lowry

    Description. This assignment is CCSS aligned. Students write a last chapte for the book, imagining what ended up happening with Jonas. This package includes the assignment, an interview with Lois Lowry regarding the ambiguous ending, peer editing forms, and a CCSS aligned rubric. Reported resources will be reviewed by our team.

  10. The Giver

    This video was created in 2012 by Ian Ross for an English class assignment to create an alternate ending for Luis Lowry's The Giver. The video features music...

  11. THE GIVER: What is an ambiguous ending?

    The students should write an alternate ending to the novel, based on their feelings, personal experiences, and the novel's textual evidence. ... The ending of The Giver is discussed openly on the net. Truly, it is left up to the individual reader to determine what became of Jonas and Gabriel. Learner Notes. The book gives many clues to a ...

  12. lois lowry

    11. At the end of The Giver, Jonas and Gabe head down through the snow to a place where there is music. Downward, downward, faster and faster. Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and they were waiting, too, for the baby. For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music.

  13. The Giver Book Ending Explained

    The ending of The Giver has sparked numerous debates and interpretations. It concludes with Jonas, the protagonist, choosing to escape from the seemingly utopian community he has grown up in. Alongside the infant Gabe, Jonas embarks on a treacherous journey towards a better future, leaving readers questioning the outcome of their escape. 1.

  14. Results for alternate ending writing

    The Giver by Lois Lowry - Alternate ending writing assignemt. Created by . TeamPanther. This assignment is CCSS aligned. Students write a last chapte for the book, imagining what ended up happening with Jonas. ... This engaging alternate ending writing assignment will have your students write their own version of a story or movie ending that ...

  15. The Giver Ending Explained

    The ending of "The Giver" is intentionally ambiguous, leaving readers with more questions than answers. Some interpret the music as a symbol of hope and freedom, suggesting that Jonas and Gabriel have successfully escaped to a better world. Others argue that the music is merely a hallucination brought on by hypothermia, implying a darker ...

  16. Alternate Endings

    To make it worse, Gabriel started to cry. Jonas tried his best to grasp onto any warm and happy memory, but the pain from his head wound stopped any happy memories from coming to his mind. He rolled onto his back, hugging Gabriel to his chest trying to get the both of them as warm as possible. The snow storm had weakened, but it was still going ...

  17. The Giver Chapter 11 Summary & Analysis

    Analysis. The Receiver places his hands on Jonas's back and transmits the memory of sledding down a hill: Jonas does not just remember the activity, he feels the cold air and the snowflakes against his face and the thrilling speed of sledding downhill. Physical contact is necessary for transmittal. Exactly how memories are "transmitted" is ...

  18. The Giver Ending, Explained

    Imagine a world without colors or emotions, or history for that matter. How would life thrive in such a place? 2014 sci-fi dystopian drama 'The Giver' is an epic tale told in snippets. Directed by Phillip Noyce and based on the eponymous 1993 young adult novel by Lois Lowry, the story revolves around the titular Giver and his Receiver in a far-flung futuristic universe.

  19. What is the ending of The Giver?

    The ending of The Giver is left intentionally ambiguous by the author. There are two main interpretations. The first is that Jonas and Gabriel die, as the text clearly depicts their physical ...

  20. The Giver by Lois Lowry

    The Giver Plot Diagram. The Giver is a dystopian science-fiction novel written by Lois Lowry and published in 1993. It is a popular novel that is often studied in schools. The primary characters ...

  21. Assignments

    Assignments are the occupations of the inhabitants of the Community. Assignments are designated when a member of the Community goes through their respective Ceremony of Twelve. All Assignments can be found here. Claire is given the Assignment of Birthmother at the Ceremony of Twelve. Coming soon... Assignments are made by the Elders may be appealed by contacting them, who form a committee to ...